Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Friday, 08 August 2008

Canberra gets an unpleasant taste of 'One China'

26/04/2008 1:13:00 PM.  | John Barrington

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST FEATURES

I saw red during the torch run.

But it wasn’t from getting particularly angry and certainly not from wearing rose-coloured glasses.

It was from the thousands of Chinese flags flapping in the wind, temporarily tattooed on the faces of cute girls - not to mention more red clothing than a Santa Claus factory outlet.

Tens of thousands of Chinese visitors and Chinese-Australians from all over the country made the trip to Canberra today.

A people so proud of their nation is a truly beautiful sight: happy faces, waving flags, singing in full voice to their national anthem, drowning out the fellow on the microphone. But what are they so proud of?

If what we're lead to believe via the world media is true, they're proud of a country that embraces militaristic Communism, a country that values men far higher than women and a country that forces its will on its neighbours, denying the people of Tibet their right to sovereignty and self-government.

Now, I've never been one of those ‘the-Asians-are-taking-over’ types, because Asians have been here since before the Gold Rush. They've done the jobs Anglos were too lazy or too 'superior' to do, and now they enjoy wealth and prosperity many of us pitch as the Great Australian Dream.

But I witnessed a scene today not too far from where the Olympic Cauldron was burning that made me question this whole patriotism thing. A small group of Anglo and Asian Free Tibet protesters were making a silent and peaceful point about human rights abuses when they were swamped and subsequently washed away by a sea of red flags.

300 hundred intimidating voices circling the protesters singing the Chinese national anthem in full-voice, in perfect harmony.

They were chanting "Liar! Liar!", "Go home!" and "One China!"

‘One China’ struck me the most, because that's the value these people were demonstrating. A nation that's main value is unity at all costs. A unified nation is a beautiful dream, but these people seemed as though they've never questioned it. And perhaps they're not to blame, with their one avenue of inquiry, the media, predominately run by the State.

Honestly, they were like robots – pre-programmed robots – capable of saying and believing only one thing: ‘One China’.

Now to be fair, this scene only represented a handful of Chinese supporters present in Canberra today. Passions were inflamed like the Olympic Cauldron and these people clearly were insulted that anyone would speak ill of their homeland, especially before rolling cameras.

But these people are clearly unfamiliar with the democratic right of protest: to the extent that in a foreign country (for many of them) they imposed a slice of totalitarian ‘do as we say - think as we say’ politics.

The main protest image plastered all over the TV networks was a Tibetan national screaming "Free Tibet!" whilst being dragged away by the police.

What wasn’t the focus is the fervent pro-China psyche, of which today I've learned more than I have in a lifetime.

In Australia, Chinese visitors have the right to swamp the capital city with red flags, wash-on tattoos and red tracksuits. But in Australia, Chinese visitors have the responsibility to accept the liberal-democratic value of "say what you want".

COMMENTS

Friday, 25 April 2008

Isn't it interesting that the pro-China brigade are quite happy to fly the communist flag here in Australia, aren't they lucky they live in a natin where they can do just that, I wonder how they would be treated in China if they flew the Australian flag, I dare say they would be carted off to gaol and their flags confiscated. I f they would prefer China, then maybe they should be shown where the various airports are in Australia.

Posted by: Stephen Hinds, Sadleir

Friday, 25 April 2008

> Stephen Hinds - You say "aren't they lucky they live in a natin where they can do just that"............ So what's your point??? Would you rather people can't display other flags in Australia (If so, Then isn't that what your complaining about in the 1st place?)

Posted by: Mitch OMatic, Sydney

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Mr. Rudd is to be commended. Australia welcomed and honored the flame, and the flame carriers for the 2008 Olympics, and the world witnessed how a peaceful relay is supposed to be carried out, by the 80 proud Australians, who earned their right to carry the torch through their contribution to society. It is truly moving to see the Chinese in support of the nation of their ancestors, displaying ethnic pride in a very positive manner. China and Australia have a very bright future together.

Posted by: Luren Tong, Hong Kong

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Mr. Rudd is to be commended. Australia welcomed and honored the flame, and the flame carriers for the 2008 Olympics, and the world witnessed how a peaceful relay is supposed to be carried out: by the 80 proud Australians, who earned their right to carry the torch through their contribution to society. It is truly moving to see the Chinese in support of the nation of their ancestors, displaying ethnic pride in a very positive manner. China and Australia have a very bright future together.

Posted by: BaaJie Zhu, Los Angeles

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Either you're so consumed by your own propaganda or you have a more sinister agenda to spread ignorance. Every country's media are tightly controlled by the state or the state's proxies (private organizations). Your country has a more sophisticated form of control than the Chinese (due to your head start in this game). Don't worry they are learning fast & will catch up soon enough. Go read the history (esp. about Tibet) instead of substituting repeated media images as gospel truth.

Posted by: John Nutt, Singapore

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

I wonder what work the Chinese did that" the Anglos were too lazy or too superior to do ". They didn't carry the night soil, the Anglos did that, they didn,t build the sewers, the Anglos did that. They were difficult to find outside the big cities before the Whitlam dream of multiculturism.

Posted by: Hector Entwhistle, Canberra

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Yet another nice Big Evil China vs Little Poor Tibet story. I applaud you, John Barrington. It's a bit unoriginal, however. The notion of Australian Chinese from various parts of Australia acting like "robots" and under China's "state control" is both ridiculous and tiring. Meanwhile, when the focus is on Tibet (a place where NOT A SINGLE country in the world recognises as a sovereign country); the United States' plan to invade Iran is in its final preparations.

Posted by: Ed Chan, Sydney

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Yet another nice Big Evil China vs Little Poor Tibet story. I applaud you, John Barrington. It's a bit unoriginal, however. The notion of Australian Chinese from various parts of Australia acting like "robots" and under China's "state control" is both ridiculous and tiring. Meanwhile, when the focus is on Tibet (a place where NOT A SINGLE country in the world recognises as a sovereign country); the United States' plan to invade Iran is in its final preparations.

Posted by: Ed Chan, Sydney

Friday, 25 April 2008

Ed. A couple of points. (1) US will not invade Iran. (2) Its not a sovreignty issue with Tibet its a brutalisation of the Tibetan people by the Chinese. (3) The Chinese media control what is fed to its people (I know, I've lived there. Me thinks you protesteth too much!

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

What we saw yesterday by the Chinese was shameful. Hatefilled and brainwashed young Chinese students trying to give legitimacy to a brutal regime. A scary look at the future of China.

Posted by: Jim Jess, Richmond

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Before anyone can comment on 'One China', know this: China was originally a nation divided until it was united as one country over 3000 years ago. It is the world's oldest continuing civilisation. The areas of Western Tibet were united with China in 57BC, Australia was colonised by the UK in 1788AD. If the media 'were' unbiased, then most westerners would know critical pieces of information such as these and there would be no need to mobilise 20,000 people to Canberra. Who's brainwashed now?

Posted by: Eddie Ho, Sydney

Friday, 25 April 2008

Why do people defend a regime that brutalises its own people, particularly ethnic minorities like the Tibetans?

Posted by: Gazza Benson, Blacktown

Friday, 25 April 2008

As an Aussie who went to the relay just out of curiosity, I was shocked to see the pro-China students aggressive behaviour and their taunting of the Tibetans. I saw numerous altercations where they surrounded Tibetans and pushed and shoved them. Their behaviour was obnoxious. I'm not at all racist, but it certainly made me wonder about letting all the Chinese students come to Australia to study, if they are really here just to work for the Communist party and create trouble.

Posted by: Tony Gillien, Canberra

Friday, 25 April 2008

There are a lot of pro-China and anti-Australia comments that reveal the true values to society of some immigrants. Why are these immigrants so desparate to flee their country and to get into our country and then, without hesitation, to criticize us? We don't migrate to their country. There is a problem either with them or with their country. As for 3000 years of the united China; it was united, and is held together with armies and gunpowder.

Posted by: Hector Entwhistle, Canberra

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

How magnanimous of you to feel sorry about a "downtrodden" people! I guess one can afford to be holier than thou when you have solved your own "original people" problems. Yes, let's march forth to teach the world (well, Chinese, no less) how shameful of them to be so brutal to their own minorities.

Posted by: john nutt, Singaopore

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Chinese people have much to be proud of. They will have more in the near future. The disgrace that is their government is not their fault alone, many in the world have wanted China to be communist and dismissive of Western values. The lunar left is never very far from the supposed centre. Some say 'Only Nixon could go to China.' But they ignore the fact that Whitlam went first. Rudd gathers about him powerful symbols of abrogation of responsibility. People see that. Kids will copy it.

Posted by: Odd Ball, Carramar/Sydney

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

Chinese students behave like robots? I wonder whether it happens before or after they receive their education in Australia. If they lose their ability to think critically after they receive their 30K a year tertiary education in Australia, then I am worried, very worried.

Posted by: john nutt, Singapore

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

I was there yesterday, with my family, including my parents and kids. We got up at 3am, and had to drive for 4 hours to Canberra. Another 4 hours on the highway in the afternoon back to Sydney. It was one of the happiest days. This morning I read a newspaper article suggesting the "red army" was a "rent-a-crowd". I was a bit disappointed, but not angry. After that many years in Australia - I do mean years - getting used to the biased media's negative coverage on China, nothing makes me angry.

Posted by: Wazza Wang, Sydney

 

Friday, 25 April 2008

But "rent-a-crowd"? I earn 6 digits a year. I took one day off. I was behind the wheel for 8 hours. I got my whole family with me and bought 2 meals for each of them at McDonald's. How much should I be paid to go there and wave a flag? I am an Chinese Australian and have been living here long enough to know it's OK to protest but it's stupid to protest against Australia's involvement in Iraq on an ANZAC Day during the parade.

Posted by: Wazza Wang, Sydney

 

Saturday, 26 April 2008

Stephen Hinds, Chinese government has no problem letting Australians display their Australian flags in China. People should know what some of the tibetans did before they talk about human rights. If WA wants to go independent, will you be so happy and supportive???

Posted by: Weina Qian, Maroubra

 

Saturday, 26 April 2008

can we have a protest on behalf of the palestinians. or must we wait till israel gets the olympics?

Posted by: trevor crook, sydney

 

Saturday, 26 April 2008

I am horrified to see all of these commies massing in Canberra and forcing their evil policies on others. China is to the 21st century, what Germany was to the 20th cenntury, these people with their pro China gangs are just like Hitlers Brownshirts. We need to boycott china, isolate it and crush it into submission. All these pro China spys and infiltrators must be sent back to China, they do not belong in the Free World, they do not deserve to be in the Free World. Crush Communism forever.

Posted by: Graeme Henderson, Darling Downs

Saturday, 26 April 2008

Oh dear, back to the fairytales! Henderson wants us to "boycott china, isolate it and crush it into submission". Hmmm, our 20+ million will make a huge impact on China's 1.3 BILLION! Any boycott would hurt Australia your infidel.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Saturday, 26 April 2008

china is not a replica of nazi germany by any stretch of the imagination. its a replica of britain when it was building its empire! as for being ' commies'. its a free market capitalist system leaning to the 'right'. always remember the aged pension, medicare, public schooling, housing and social services, things that all australians benefit from, were socialist [commie] ideas. so have a little gratitude!

Posted by: trevor crook, sydney

Saturday, 26 April 2008

1.3 billion vs 20+ million, let's put into prospective, if it is not because the Chinese government positive policies in last twenty years, do you think WA resources boom would happen, cheaper chinese goods keep retail price low thus having positive inflence on inflation. If there are not large number of Chinese students studying Australia, how would all oz universities survive the short fall of funding. Show some gratitudes and repect to China and Chinese people, China is not Gemany.

Posted by: sam zhao, Sydney

Thursday, 01 May 2008

I believe most of these Pro-China Chinese are Pro-freedom and Pro-democracy too. The problem happened when Pro-tibet activatists used violent to disrupt torch relay, which were seen along the beginning, I have to say they lost sympathy of majority Chinese people all around the world. Can you Imagine aboriginal people used same tactic to voice their opinion during 2000 sydney Olimpic? As soon as Chinese mobilized to voice their stand, they become bullys. Tic for tug, I am afraid.

Posted by: david huang, westmead

 

Saturday, 26 April 2008

Here we go again. Yet another state that believes totalitarianism is a really good idea, and won't hesitate to crush any in its path, so long as its small and easy to crush of course - typical baby, cowardly, bullying approach. All the usual propaganda mythology, all the usual rewriting of history - one china (ha!), we are united, we are superior in every way, your intellect is inferior, your culture is inferior, you have no culture. What cry-baby rubbish ! Sorry, heard it all before. Sick of it

Posted by: steve smith, sydney

 

Sunday, 27 April 2008

COMMUNISM ??? There is a party called communist party in china but there is no more communism. The gathering in canberra is show the FREE thought of oversea chinese people. We are no ROBOT , we have our own free thinking.

Posted by: michael M, melbourne

 

Sunday, 27 April 2008

There is atleast 20 million of chinese world wide keeping their's eyes on you and the Free World Wide Internet all the way up to the Olympic War Games in an attempt to protect the Fatherland of China and the 100 % Economical and the Political Games taking place in August. Australia 2020 Summitter's was 1.000 people and the Chinese protester's during the Torch Relay was 1.000, too. Wow, it's scary. China have already sophisticatedly invaded the Internet and successfully made a cencor on it....

Posted by: Ture Sjolander, Lismore

 

Sunday, 27 April 2008

Beside this, Why are the Han-Chinese dominating China and Why is there approx. 90 million chinese families who are more rich and multi-billionaires, than any westerner? Class and discrimination is more than obvious in China now. What will happen from this population composition within a decade from now? The dominating people in Australia has it own "Han" group of aussies, the Anglo-maniacs....and they are in minority of the total population. Very tribal world!

Posted by: Ture Sjolander, Byronbay

 

Sunday, 27 April 2008

No one should accused any countryman stand up for their own nation's cause and value, including Autralian. It is nothing to do with which political system each country is based. You only scared that there are so many Chinese, this is not a secret. The only way you compete, is to extend the last government's policy, one for dad, one for mum and one for the government, get off internet, making double or triple of the number,so one day here you could have 1.3 billion people, see how you feed all.

Posted by: sam zhao, sydney

Sunday, 27 April 2008

Yeah I heard this before while working in Jilin Province and in Beijing; "being afraid because the chinese are so many", but that is only parly true and it do not apply for me personally, although quantity make sense if one consider each person as an insurgent and brainwashed from childhood. I also got the accurate info about the 90 million multi-billionaires from good sources of young clever chinese students. Last Friday Anzac Day coincided with the Malaria Day in accordance to U.N.

Posted by: Ture Sjolander, Mullumbimby

 

Sunday, 27 April 2008

I really appreciate this peaceful protest on youtube. It took a while to work out the signs. http://youtube.com/watch?v=yi2rBu1t-Yk I guess that protests will be few and far in Vietnam and North Korea

Posted by: Odd Ball, Carramar/Sydney

 
 

YOUR SAY