Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Cash for kidneys? Doctor demands commercial kidney donation

5/05/2008 5:42:00 PM.  | John Barrington & Anil Lambert-Patel

A leading Canberra doctor says healthy Australians should be allowed to sell their organs to those waiting for transplant operations.

The government and medical groups have rejected the controversial idea, saying it would exploit the vulnerable

But Canberra doctor Gavin Carney says drastic measures are needed to save lives because the current system is not working.

“It’s not working particularly for my patients,” he told a news conference in the ACT.

“I have patients who are coming onto dialysis relatively fit, relatively young, staying on dialysis for a protracted period of time and at the end of that they either die or they’re so unfit they’re untreatable anyway.

"The cadaveric kidney donation system doesn't work. Efforts to improve that have been notoriously weak and have failed.

"In my mind we need to reconsider the entire program and become a little bit more practical and a little bit more pragmatic."

But Organ transplant groups have rejected calls for healthy people to be able to sell their organs to desperate patients.

Kidney Australia Director Dr Tim Matthews says allowing people to charge up to $50,000 for their body parts would only attract the poor and desperate.

“The only people who put their hands up to do this will be those who are desperate,” he claimed.

“We think that’s unfair, particularly [because] there’s no precedent for trading in body parts in Australia - it’s against our culture.”

There are currently some 1,800 people on the waiting list for a kidney but Australian laws prevent buying and selling organs.

LIVENEWS.com.au will bring you video from Dr Carney's news conference shortly.

COMMENTS

Monday, 05 May 2008

We should be able to sell our own kidneys, but not anyone else's. I know something of the pain of waiting for an organ, my sister died after she waited many years for one, but (early days of the surgery) she (her body) rejected one she got. She could have carried on, but she was tired of dialysis. At the moment, our culture is formed by the politics of one party promoting envy, not responsible management. Hence opposition to water recycling plans, wealth, personal success or philanthropy.

Posted by: Indie Fatigue ah Ball, Carramar/Sydney

 

Monday, 05 May 2008

It would seem to be a very good idea at first - but where there is big money on offer, organized crime follows. There are people whose lives aren't under their own control and they would be the first ones exploited by the slash for cash scheme presented here. Crime bosses and pimps would have no hesitation ordering their 'possessions' to cough up a kidney and hand over the cash. Slaves do as they are told.

Posted by: Jeff Citizen, Melbourne

 

Monday, 05 May 2008

personally i think the best way to solve this problem is to simply say everyone is an assumed future organ donor unless they opt out, that way there is no loss of rights and all that garbage. we can't have people waiting decades on waiting lists while possible matching organs goto waste in the next hospital bed seperated only by politicl ideology. jeff citizen: we're all slaves when the money in the bank runs out

Posted by: chris slaveking, democratic crusaders alliance

 

Tuesday, 06 May 2008

Should_you_be_ALLOWED_to_sell_your_kidney? Of course, not! That may make you peons think that you have a right to self-ownership or something..

Posted by: jack f, east

 

Tuesday, 20 May 2008

I would totally sell my kidney, to help someone else as well as myself. It's a win-win situation - there's nothing in any way wrong with this. Surely medical science is advanced enough to do this safely and cheaply. What difference does it make if the scheme tends to attract the financially challenged? As long as the kidney is healthy, that's all that matters.

Posted by: Shaun Moss, Brisbane

 

Saturday, 31 May 2008

If some one need to buy 100% healthy kidney, here I am male 34 of age, and us citizen, no smoking, no drinking, and no alcoholic either. I need about up to $100.000us dollars to help my family emergency. Contact me by phone (702) 481-8469 or email me I will sell my healthy kidney to you right away.

Posted by: Thao Nguyen, Las Vegas

 

Wednesday, 01 October 2008

Im 40 good health I would be willing to sell mine call ***********

Posted by: Jay jayman2000, fayetteville,AR

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
Register to receive daily news and sports details

YOUR SAY

Its interesting how people (with a possible vested interest?) jump to causal conclusions before any of the facts are available for analysis? Let's see what... Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove on 'Systems failure' caused terrifying 3000m Qantas plunge

What? Good grief, Jan. I certainly hope you are under a physicians care. Those two sentences made no sense, at all. ... Pithy Opiner, Stockton, California on One killed, hundreds injured as Thai protests explode into violence

This women is a goldigger. Nothing she says is credible. Stop wasting the publics time.... Andy Shaver, Sydney on Mills calls for breast milk to replace cow milk

I don't believe the aircraft fell 3000m but time will tell. The pre-departure safety PA is very clear stating, "it is a company requirement that... Paul Trood, Southport on 'Systems failure' caused terrifying 3000m Qantas plunge

SILENCE...I KILL YOU!!!!... Gina S, st pete on 'Achmed the Dead Terrorist' ban sparks global debate