Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Friday, 05 December 2008

McKinnon got off lightly: Gallop, coaches

5/09/2008 11:02:00 AM.  | Peter Cassidy
NRL boss David Gallop has slammed the three match ban imposed on Wade McKinnon for spitting at a touch judge, insisting it was too lenient and demanding harsher penalties for players caught disrespecting match officials.

The Warriors have a different take on the matter, claiming the penalty is unfair after their application to appeal was thrown out by judiciary chairman Greg Woods.

Unsurprisingly, rival NRL coaches have sided with Gallop.

Speaking with News Limited, Gallop said: "We fully support the process and the jury of ex-players making a decision but in this case, on the face of it, the penalty appears to be too light."

While the NRL won't step in on this occasion, Gallop has warned of actions which could influence future cases.

"The NRL board has an ability to make a directive regarding future judiciary issues," Gallop told News Limited

"As there is a board meeting (today), we will be recommending that where there is a clear finding of a player spitting at an official, we would expect a suspension of months, not weeks. Therefore this case will not necessarily operate as a precedent into the future."

Gold Coast coach John Cartwright is amongst those supporting Gallop's stance, insisting the penalty should have been months, not weeks.

"It sends a poor message to everyone involved in the game," Cartwright told News Limited.

"I'd rather be punched in the head than spat on. Spitting on a touch judge - it should be eight weeks minimum. What's the next bloke going to get?"

Penrith steer Matt Elliott agreed.

"He (McKinnon) is lucky. If our game has a standard punishment that says if you spit at a touch judge, you get three weeks, then that's too lenient.

"He should buy a 'scratchy'."

COMMENTS

Friday, 05 September 2008

If McKinnon is lucky then this is a disgrace to the NRL. If he deliberately spat at an official then he should be gone for at least 12 months. Personally, I feel that he didn't aim at the touchie, but this light penalty is just to make the judiciary look good. Instead they look extremely foolish. McKinnon should either have got off or got 12 months.UJFNGZ

Posted by: bill pollock, Warilla

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
Register to receive daily news and sports details

YOUR SAY

Rudd's policies keep contradicting themselves. At the one end of the pendulum, you have Rudd guaranteeing all bank deposits for the next 3 years... Aurora Australis, Melbourne, http://aurora-australis.proboards.com on Will we spend or save Rudd's billions?

Lol @ Adrian. If you went to a Catholic school and didn't have the Australian Anthem, you must have had your school confused with something... susan lawe, wherever on Islamic school denies banning National Anthem

How refreshing, for a bloke who has been wedged in the Rodent's coinslot for the past 12 years, you show a rare appreciation for the... darren carrow, brisbane on Turnbull under leadership cloud as senators rebel

Andy Mac-And wait there’s more. Remember the way Rudd and his cronies used to criticise the Coalition for what they called 'Political Advertising’. Now they... Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill on Kevin Rudd spends $600,000 on travel

Religion=poor man's psychotherapy.... Observer JWH Party, Australia on Atheists sue over billboard removal