Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Sunday, 12 October 2008

Real question being asked about Rudd's leadership

30/05/2008 12:50:00 PM.  | Alan Jones

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST FEATURES

It's been a horrendous week for the Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd. But for many I'm sure it hasn't been a surprising week.

Those who know the man would hardly be surprised.

As Dennis Shanahan writing today in The Australian says, "Mr Rudd must either change his style or face more debilitating crises such as this week's petrol price disaster". And he made the point that there's no doubting the intent behind the leaks.

He said the leaks from government and the public service go to the issue of the conduct, direction and style of the Rudd government.

Dennis Shanahan talks about deep rifts within the Cabinet and a view within the public service that good policy is being sacrificed to solve publicity stunts.

Indeed, he argues that the Rudd Government is ill-defined "except for symbolism and stunts".

"There are Labor figures,” he writes, “who are concerned that micro-management and media manipulation are no substitute for having a leader with a broad and substantive policy direction".

That's shorthand for what I've been saying. No grasp of detail.

As Dennis Shanahan says, "This week's leaks, wherever they came from, underline the fact that unless the Government can articulate what it stands for then it can't hope to hide behind stunts that don't deliver".

Well, it's not just petrol.

An inexperienced government with a totally inexperienced leader doesn't understand that once you start alienating minorities and they together become anti-government, they form a powerful majority.

Taxing family cars costing more than 50-odd thousand dollars was always a nonsense policy, especially when the cost of the vehicle is most probably related to its safety and its green credentials.

But then you've got the mental health issue.

Fancy taking over $300 million away from those with mental illness.

Or half a billion from farmers drowning in drought.

Or scrapping the Simpson Prize, an Anzac day tour giving schoolchildren the chance to visit Gallipoli.

It only costs $170,000.

Then there's the alcopop nonsense.

Increase the tax on it, so now kids are mixing their own drinks from spirits which carry less of a tax. How can that be public policy of any kind?

But then any number of inquiries, committees and reviews in the handful of months since Mr Rudd became the government. More than 100 new reviews, summits and agencies. We're drowning in the stuff.

And then sensing trouble, Mr Rudd starts manipulating the media, and the ABC, amongst others, complaining of what is "verging on thuggery".

"People are abusing their positions in this place."

As the Victorian Liberal Senator Michael Ronaldson said, "This is a Government in six months that's totally out of control."

Remember, a Government that has managed to upset Japan, which for months was ignored and left off the Prime Minister's 18 day overseas world tour.

But not averse to spending money where it's of no demonstrable benefit.

The jaunt to sign the Kyoto Protocol in Bali last year cost almost half a million dollars.

Mr Rudd's hospitality for two nights in Bali, two nights, almost $40,000.

And he took with him five Ministers, 12 Ministerial staff and 35 bureaucrats to sign off on Kyoto.

While we're grinding under the need for infrastructure reform, we get no decisions other than $75 million in the Budget for, you guessed it, a study to consider how to proceed with a number of infrastructure projects.

And on top of all of this, the real crisis for Kevin Rudd this week in ignoring the advice of four major departments over FuelWatch.

There are serious rumblings within the government over the leadership.

Dennis Shanahan is right when he refers to Labor figures who today "are concerned that micro-management and media manipulation are no substitute for having a leader with a broad and substantive policy direction".

Mr Rudd does not have that.

Indeed, he never has. But it will be interesting to see where he goes if he doesn't soon find one.

What we've seen this week may be the tip of a policy iceberg.

COMMENTS

Friday, 30 May 2008

At this stage it looks like the public service revolting against Rudd but the next revelation will be that it is actually the Labor party itself that is "bucking' him. We knew this from when he first became their leader 18 months ago - Kevin Rudd is no more than a salesman for the true Labor party who have hidden behind his palateable, economic conservative image to get themselves in power. Truth is they all hate his guts as much as the Liberals and can't wait to be rid of him. Watch this space.

Posted by: Jo Stalin, Sydney

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

Crash and burn! Mr Rudd needs to clean up his act. the man is useless this country will be in serious trouble if he continues like this. Great Article Alan, hopefully more people who believed Mr Rudd was going to make this a better country will now understand he is nothing but a show pony

Posted by: Tom Lee, Woodcroft

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

I did not vote for him, I presumed he was all gilz & glammour & then he would be a bulk standard labor leader, but he really isn't....he's quite scary. His decisions are irratic & seem to hurt nearly everyone. This is a genuine question, can anyone name a group of people/portfolio that has actually benefited from anything Rudd has done? If so can you tell me who & how they've been helped? Between my family & I we cross a number of demographics & he hasn't helped us.

Posted by: Concerned Liberal, Minto

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

Good summary Alan. What concerns me is what happens if this country were to have a real crisis. I shudder to think how Rudd would react to something serious without his mountains of notes and the time to call enquires. If we have a major terrorist attack or natural disaster, how many committees and enquiries is he going to have to call before he will come up with a response to the situation. He is nothing more than a star struck salesman and i find that really scary!

Posted by: Chrissie S, Mooloolaba

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

The labor party was heavily backed by the unions-I hope people start to realise the soviet style of politics reeling it's ugly head - not only is Rudd erratic he is risking everyone's future in this country-this collusion has continued to be covered up for too long it has run rampant in the public sector, ALL politicians are accountable to the public and so is Rudd- he's only a front man for the labor party bordering on complete madness which brings to question the style of govt in place!

Posted by: Dan Concerned, *

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

Up until this time Kevin Rudd has been allowed to get away with presenting a false image of himself. Large sections of the Media helped along the way. They never questioned him on the details of the economic effects of his IR and extreme climate change policies. He was allowed to defer every thing to a committee or an inquiry. As soon as he actually has to do something, as opposed to just talking about it, he has proved to be a failure. Examples of this are the Budget (will not help with inflation) and the so called petrol watch. Is it just coincidence that since he took office most of the economic indicators are heading in the wrong direction?

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Saturday, 31 May 2008

Good points, the economy relies on business and businesses take risks, its about deciding how far to stick your neck out under a particular economic/political environment, same goes for people wanting to borrow money for say an investment property (that’s been going bad in NSW for a few years, thanks to NSW ALP) (in relation to sticking your neck out) its just seems now businesses have done a turtle sh ting it self.

Posted by: Bart R, Sydney

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

Will Mr Rudd bend or break under this pressure? If he breaks he will use his health as an excuse to escape. Remember he has had heart trouble in the past. If that happens what will be even worse is that Ms Gillard will then be running the country. God help us all if that happens.

Posted by: Phil A, Central Coast

Friday, 30 May 2008

That is an interesting scenario and not that far-fetched. It would be a perfect way to sneak the thin-lipped one into the top job - which is off-course every union hack's and "true-believer's" wet dream. Long live the revolution.

Posted by: Jo Stalin, Sydney

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

This is hardly a surprise. All liberal voters likely knew this since last year. The guy has no substance. Period. Unfortunately 53% of Australians brought into Rudd's rhetorics, spin, and lies. So Australians deserve what they have chosen - you made the beds, not lie in it!

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

I would be horrified to see Ms Gillard running this country. She truly is scary and not quite sane i think. I long for the old days where Howard and Costello just fought over the leadership continually; yet they made time to make sure this trillion dollar econony stayed on track. Sometimes we dont know what we had until we loose it. Peter...where are you??? Peter...can you hear me...you need to come back and sort this **** out! While your here you could sharpen up Malcom too for the future.

Posted by: Chrissie S, Mooloolaba

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

Interestingly, all the old favourite "lefties" have again evaporated. Rudd really has shown his colours here, and it doesn't look good. I've always thought him to a bit of a dummy spitter. Now we need to dig up Rudd's role in the Queensland government's decision to destroy documents in the Heiner affair?? Now that really would liven things up!

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Friday, 30 May 2008

Hey "Bolts" ..... Rudd and the subtle art of Heiner document shredding! Where did that get to? Haven't seen much investigative journalism on that!

Posted by: Gary Benson, Blacktown

Friday, 30 May 2008

Bensa! Not sure. Does anyone out there have an update on Rudd's Heiner affair document shredding escapade??

Posted by: bolts Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

To all my loyal Liberal Friends it warms my heart to see you all still Fighting the good fight.BUT you need to be patient for a while yet,Because you see I left RUDD knee deep in MY SH*T and we don't want to take over until he FIXES up everything,Then my dear Friends we will strike like we did before with Keating.We don't want to Govern when times are Tough,Let Rudd do all the hard work then we will reap the rewards again.Understand!

Posted by: JOHN W HOWARD, Dapto

Friday, 30 May 2008

Anyone know when Rudd is going to start doing something that he promised? If so please tell Dapto.

Posted by: Gary Benson, Blacktown

Friday, 30 May 2008

JOHN W HOWARD, Dapto-Rudd has absolutely no problem in creating his own Sh*t. Every time he opens his mouth he creates volumes of it and of course the Labor faithful enjoy every discharge.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Friday, 30 May 2008

Des - do you have any update on Rudd and the Heiner document shredding affair?

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Friday, 30 May 2008

It seems Dapto is a place which produces labor supporting mobs who specialise in personification of dignitaries such as Paul Keating or John W Howard. Unfortunately these mobs from Dapto give people an impression that the place is full of sh*t as none of what these Dapto mobs utter from their mouths makes sense. By the way, one would have thought that there is legal ramification to utter rubbish while pretend speaking on behalf of someone else?

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Friday, 30 May 2008

Dapto youre a strange person.

Posted by: Bart R, Sydney

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

Don't worry, if Kev wears down Ms Gillard is ready to jump into the job. The fe males and the Party will rejoice because we will be led by (for a time) a fe male Prime Minister with a female Govenor.

Posted by: Hector Entwhistle, Canberra

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

This is only the start. Eventually, and probably soon, Rudd's career will be shredded finer than his Heiner documents.

Posted by: Happy Fun Ball, Carramar/Sydney

 

Friday, 30 May 2008

No surprise. I believe Jason Morrison has the ability to investigate into the Heiner affair. It wouldn’t surprise me if he’s on the case as we speak. I imagine it would be a very carefully thought out delicate investigation, wouldn’t want to make too many ripples during investigation as it may cause more shredding. As for Alan Jones, as usual you have hit the nail on the head with a sledge hammer; the scary thing is this has all happened in 6 months, not a good sign at all. Keep it up AJ

Posted by: Bart R, Sydney

 

Saturday, 31 May 2008

As I put in another forum: THE KEVIN RUDD CURE-ALL Gather Australians (whichever most politically convenient group) around "a kitchen table",compliment them for being "the working families that they are", apologize for not having a "silver bullet",unfold a "blueprint for Australia's future", remind them of your "apology",use the word "CLEARLY" a thousand times,keep your sideburns sharp,do a bit of pushing down of the upward pressure; and,mate,they're in the palm of his hands -PROBLEM SOLVED

Posted by: Paul Williams, Sydney

 

Saturday, 31 May 2008

Well, after 6 months of this socialist joke of a prime minister and his quasi-communist government, I think it's time the Liberal party took action! Bugger what the retarded public voted for, it's time for the RIGHTFUL party of government to block supply and get back into POWER where they belong! And then, watch out Australia, because it'll be time for REVENGE for what you ungrateful little mongrels dared to do to Mr Howard! WHO'S WITH ME???

Posted by: Bob Philips, Stirling

Sunday, 01 June 2008

Bob Phillips of Stirling, you are seriously vacuous and delusional. After 12 years of Dark Ages and Communism under this despotic Mugabe-ite Little Johnny Pinocchio, the right political party (ie. the True Believers) are here to save the world from low productivity instigated by the Liberal Communists under the draconian JerkChoices along with reforming health and education. As for David the Happy Camper Oddball, get used to your beloved criminal idols ending up extinct like the dodo bird.

Posted by: Jess T, *

Sunday, 01 June 2008

Jess T, are you on the same planet as us? You are calling the last 12 years in which Australians enjoyed unprecedented wealth, low unemployment, low interest rate & inflation as "dark ages" and liberal party as "communist? What are you calling Rudd & his communist like policies? Low productivity from liberal govt? What then will you call these various strikes from Qantas workers and teachers etc since Rudd took office last Nov? Man, I never knew labot voters can be so out of touch!

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Sunday, 01 June 2008

Looks like Jess swallowed the dictionary this morning!

Posted by: Gary Benson, Blacktown

Sunday, 01 June 2008

Thank you, Gary and W O, for expressing your support for me against these leftist spastics trying to victimise me and discriminate against me for my political beliefs! Hopefully together, we can help get this country get back on track, and CRUSH the bleeding-heart do-gooder pinko fairies like Jess who want to destroy our Australian way of life! SOLIDARITY, BROTHERS!!!

Posted by: Bob Philips, Stirling

Sunday, 01 June 2008

Bob, There is never a shortage of misled leftwingers here defending everything & anything Rudd said or do as if he is god & whatever he utters is treated as gospel. I often thought if I was a labor voter last year I will now be so ashamed that I simply won't say anything than saying something that defiles my conscience. In 6 months Rudd has stuffed up all critical aspects of society-interest, inflation, grocery, petrol, etc. The only promises he delivered are all ideologies such as Kyoto!

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

Wednesday, 04 June 2008

WO: Good to see you are Claiming Bob Phillips as one of your Mates.His rantings must strike a chord with you.

Posted by: Paul Keating The 2nd, Dapto

Wednesday, 04 June 2008

Keating, I think he strikes a chord with about half the population (that is the half that DIDN'T make the mistake of voting for Mr Sheen, sorry, the Milky Bar Kid!). I hope that you are aware that Rudd's HUGE MANDATE, is that half of the country agreed to five his lies a go, and the other half didn't.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 04 June 2008

Paul, at least Bob's "ranting" is cleaner and rational than the discharge from you labor voters who normally resort to rhetorics and, most of all, often personal attack when a debate is lost.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra

 

Sunday, 01 June 2008

Here's a challenge Rudd....Either REMOVE the advantageous excxise arrangement in QLD or give the whole country an 8c reduction in fuel excise. (Brendan, you are Ok to "me-too" that idea if you want!)

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Sunday, 01 June 2008

While a lot of the above comments are justified, you need to look a bit further. Both sides are dirty and you have no choice my Aussie friends. It is just a game you play every few years. Your Mr Rudd is doing no more or no less than your ex, Mr Howard did. I am afraid you are doomed to this misery for many years to come. It is just a club for a few wealthy boys and girls to control the rest of you rabble. Sorry to put it in a more truthful way, but someone has too.

Posted by: Garry Ward, Hong Kong

Sunday, 01 June 2008

Garry Ward HK: Very truthful comments and agreement from me.However you will cop criticism because you said both sides are dirty!It is a game and provides good topics for Debate,But some people believe their Party is Clean and you will hear from them.Keep commenting.

Posted by: Gazza Rowe, Brisbane

Sunday, 01 June 2008

What is the Government in Hong Kong like? Is there any likelihood of an opposition winning Government there?.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Sunday, 01 June 2008

The last time I checked Hong Kong's leader can only be appointed by the govt in Beijing & people in HK have no say in it! So at least Australia is better than Hong Kong in this respect. As for both parties being "dirty" - well there will always be good politicians & bad ones on both sides, & this forum contains comments from supporters of both sides. We should not be distracted by this-rather we should concentrate on Rudd's lies as he is now in govt! Blaming opposition will not get you anywhere.

Posted by: W O, Turramurra