Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Wednesday, 03 December 2008

Experts losing hope for lost whale

20/08/2008 10:55:00 PM.  | Annika Burgess with Richard Maxton

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST FEATURES

Euthanasia may be the only option for a baby whale lost in waters north of Sydney, after it was apparently abandoned by its mother.

Wildlife services said that the humpback whale calf, which appears to be only two to three weeks old, won’t be able to survive without the care provided by a mother.

NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service spokesman John Dengate has told 2GB’s Jason Morrison his staff have all been affected by the ‘heart wrenching’ situation.

Desperate for care, the calf - which has been dubbed 'Colin' - has been nuzzling up to whale-sized yachts, seemingly mistaking the vessels for its mother.

“Normally whales stay very, very close to their mothers. They're inseparable and they suckle for 11 months before being weaned,” Mr Dengate said.

A number of options have been investigated such as captive care, and even trying to find another whale to adopt it – but without the time, money and resources these things can’t be done.

Mr Dengate said despite a flood of support from concerned Sydney-siders, the whale has slim chances of survival.

“It’s the hardest issue I’ve ever seen in this sort or regard.”

Trevor Long, the marine service director at Sea World on the Gold Coast, today recommended the animal be euthanased.

"We have considered all possibilities and exhausted all possible rescue scenarios and along with other experts in the field, we agree the animal's suffering should not be prolonged, and advocate for a humane outcome," he said.

The calf is currently at Pittwater, in the Basin area, swimming around the yachts – people are being advised to keep their distance.

COMMENTS

Wednesday, 20 August 2008

Poor whale.........but thats life. I say call in the Japanese to deal with it. I'm sure it could be all cleaned up but this afternoon...anyone got the whaling hotline number......and the best thing is they'll pick up and haul the mess away.

Posted by: Jack May, sydney

 

Wednesday, 20 August 2008

I think you're right, Jack. The Japanese could solve your problem post-haste. They have the boats to do it, too. They could have that calf in little tin cans on your grocery shelves in a matter of days!! That's how fast they are. I'll give them a call for you guys.

Posted by: Pithy Opiner, California, USA

Wednesday, 20 August 2008

Probably the Japanese got her mother too!! That will be one way of reuniting them but that will certainly not be a happy ending.

Posted by: Sam. Metusela, Figtree

 

Wednesday, 20 August 2008

I suggest that the young whale be left where it is, and be fed some appropriate formular approved by wildlife experts from the boat it has " adopted " as its mother. There would be plenty of volunteers, who would love the opportunity to assist it, on a roster system.

Posted by: Margaret Walsh, Sydney

 

Wednesday, 20 August 2008

Isn't nature wild eh? But don't fool yourselves into thinking that Euthanasia is being considered just for the whales sake, it's really to put the people out of their misery. I hope that all the anti Euthanasia people get out and save it. I suspect this is the result of shark nets or military sonar experiments or both. Get rid of shark nets if you really give a damn about whales, and stop the military with their sick experiments.

Posted by: Graeme Henderson, Darling Downs

 

Wednesday, 20 August 2008

What to do....omg...what are we going to do? If you ask KRUDD, hold a review. If you ask me...let nature do what nature does. It is after all, nature that has taken care of the mother. Margaret, i think ity's been said by seaworld vets etc that its not possible to do what you said. Probably an issue wioth finding suitable formula....It seems supermarkets shelves are empty odf said formula at present. Oh Well...the sharks need to feed to.

Posted by: Nick Again, Maryborough

 

Thursday, 21 August 2008

Whatever can be done should be done. I actually find it distasteful that someone can suggest that Euthanasia would be done for our benefit and not the whale, if we were so heartless as a community then the easy option would surely be to take it out to open water and let "nature take its course" . While we may be able to do much for this poor whale I do find it heartening that Sydney is concerned and as a community is rallying to help in whatever way it can.

Posted by: Sharyn Kean, Sydney

 

Thursday, 21 August 2008

Very cogent point, Nick Again. I never thought about in like that. But, yes, sharks need food, too. Forget euthanasia. Let nature takes it course. Drag the baby out to deep water and let the sharks take care of the problem. You kill two birds with one stone, that way. If you euthanize it there in the harbor, you're just going to have to haul it up and bury it someplace. That would be a waste of manpower and money!! Good thinking, Nick.

Posted by: Pithy Opiner, California, USA

 

Thursday, 21 August 2008

I would like this to reach John Dengate. If it is true that the baby whale is trying to suckle from a boat, then the baby itself is telling us how to help it. Use a boat as a surrogate mother. Pass a feeding tube down beside the boat and flood the water with milk. He will find it. Then put the feeding tube where a mothers nipple would be and gradually release the milk. He's desperate and looking for help. He's trying to survive otherwise he would just have stayed out at sea and died.

Posted by: Vicki Ingham, West Pennant Hills

 

Thursday, 21 August 2008

I do think that the baby whale Colin's mother had her to get the baby bonus and with that money she went and bought a HD plasma/LCD TV ! Probably she is watching olympics and hence abandoned her baby. I feel sorry for you Colin. Blame Costello for all this.

Posted by: Prakash Bhat, Rydalmere

 

Thursday, 21 August 2008

where are all the japanese whaling boats at present?? just wondering if they got the mother?

Posted by: Belinda Hummie, New lambton

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

And yet the world can band together and save whales trapped in ice in the Arctic. The US can get themselves organised to redirect a lost whale swimming the wrong way up a River. We can't appeal to the world to help with a baby whale that seems to have the will to live? Just appalling. Embarrassing. We didn't even bother to give ANY of the ideas a go...not one...not one single attempt. Everything chucked in the too hard basket. What happened to the Australian Can Do Attitude. I'm ASHAMED.

Posted by: Allison Kinniburgh, Adelaide

 

Sunday, 24 August 2008

Its amazing that so many people are passionate about this. But in the end EXPERTS came to the decision for the euthanasia because in the long term that was the best option. It would be amazing to feed a baby whale until it was weaned but what would happen after that? How would we teach it the appriopate sounds and signals that it would need to join a pod once it was weaned? Would be great if we had the procedures in place in case it (but hoping it wouldn't) happened again

Posted by: Kate Lee, Neutral Bay

 

Sunday, 24 August 2008

Really Australia take some tips from a third world country as you all say (South Africa). You all know that you could have done something to save collette. It was just too hard for you all to Too easy to euthanase. Anyway the whole world is looking at your country and saying Shame !!!!!! You all only found out after she was euthanased that Colin was a girl. Shows how much research and interest was taken in the little baby calf.

Posted by: Faye Kinsey, Balmoral

Sunday, 24 August 2008

Faye, perhaps you should be in Australia as a consultant for situations like this if you know so much? What would you have proposed people do? Furthermore, I'd like you to keep in mind the whole of Australia didn't have a say. It would have taken months to get everyone to vote on what we could do to save Collette, and by then it would have been too late anyway. I am sad Collette's life was so short, but if you're going to criticise, at least be specific and accurate.

Posted by: Amy BG, Brisbane

Sunday, 24 August 2008

The only reason the world will look on in disgust is A.) We took so long to shoot it. B.) We didnt cut it up and feed it to the animals in the Zoo where the Autopsy took place.

Posted by: Nick Again, here n There

 

Monday, 25 August 2008

I'm sorry Faye. We didn't do the right thing & I'm ashamed of being an Australian with what has happened to Collette. The public and wildlife groups really did want her saved, but Wildlife organisations and public were prevented by bureaucratic nonsense, National parks and wildlife service and police were there to prevent anyone going near the whale at the end. Sea Shepherds(a wildlife group) had actually taken out an injunction to stop the whale from being put down & they had milk ready 2 go.

Posted by: Simone S, Queensland

 

Monday, 25 August 2008

Let's think of this as a marine calf becoming veal, don't hear of a major public about the fattening up and slaughtering of baby cattle do we? A veal schnitzel is a very popular and sought after dish in Australia and many other western countries, is it not?

Posted by: Richard Hampton, Surry Hills

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
Register to receive daily news and sports details

YOUR SAY

Wow, such talent you quote, guy AND Shannon! Hang on, let me write that down. Now thats quality!... jenny jenkins, perth on Hit or miss? Media confusion over Wes Carr single sales

Julia , BMG's "Angels brought me here " gave me, and still gives me more goose bumps than the first time i ever... S lick, WA on Hit or miss? Media confusion over Wes Carr single sales

IMHO, the whole lot of them carry on like a group of Bitchy cats...A very sad predicamentfor our pollitics and a very shamefull display to... Nick Again, Maryborough on Julie Bishop defends Question Time 'clawing'

susan women are looking at the ceiling wondering when their husband is going to get around to painting it. or working out the shopping list.... Belinda Hummie, New lambton on Giant orgasm planned for late December

Andy Shaver, Wes doing a country album are you for real ?.Wes does and sings what Sony BMG says. He may have the versatility to... S lick, WA on Hit or miss? Media confusion over Wes Carr single sales