Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Wednesday, 03 December 2008

We could have done more: Sydney researchers admit they could have saved Colette

23/08/2008 8:00:00 AM.  | LIVENEWS.com.au with AAP

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST FEATURES

Sydney researchers who struggled to save an orphaned whale admit they could have done more.

Animal activists heckled authorities at Pittwater over the way the baby humpback was put down with a lethal injection.

Wildlife authorities say they'll begin considering ideas to save whales that become stranded in similar situations in the future.

But the RSPCA's Steve Coleman says there was nothing else they could have done .

“That animal was in the throes of dying. We would have been surprised if it had survived another day.”

Earlier

It’s been revealed that the recently euthanized abandoned baby humpback whale, affectionately referred to as Colin, was in fact a girl.

Now being renamed Colette, the discovery was made after the calf’s remains were taken to Sydney’s Taronga Zoo.

"They'll do a post-mortem to actually see what condition it was in and to actually see what might have been the problem," Barnes said.

The month old calf was given an overdose of anesthetic, after authorities found her in a bad way this morning.

She was having trouble breathing, and suffering bad cuts.

The calf was put down behind the breakwater at The Basin, in Sydney’s Pittwater – it took seven injections before the drugs finally took effect.

Colette could be seen moving in the water for up to 10 minutes, and was still thrashing around when dragged to shore.

In a last bid to try and save her, local activists served an injunction on national parks to try and stop them, but it couldn’t be served in time.

Animal welfare groups insisted there was nothing more they could do to save her.

John Dengate from the NPWS says his team had exhausted all possible options.

“It’s been I think on everyone’s mind – couldn’t you just do something, couldn’t you just feed it, can’t you get it out to a pod of whales?

“What I would say to those people is that we’ve tried every single technique that anyone with any kind of standing in the industry has suggested.”

Meanwhile, a whale carcass found off the NSW south coast not far from Eden may possibly be Colette's mother.

According to National Parks and Wildlife Sservices (NPWS) director Sally Barnes authorities hope DNA tests will shed some light on Colette’s tragic death.

"That carcass is being eaten by sharks at the moment," Barnes told AAP.

"If it's safe, what we'll try and do is actually get some DNA from that carcass to see whether that was in fact Colette's mother and to help us piece together what's been happening to that whale over the last week or so."

 

COMMENTS

Friday, 22 August 2008

Should of called him Kevin,not Colin,then he could of walked on the water.

Posted by: Tung Yan, around the next bend

Friday, 22 August 2008

Oh Yeah! I like it. But it would have only lasted for a while before he would have sunk as the liberal surface tension was broken.

Posted by: Dennis Bradney, Mission Beach

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Yeah, kill it. Don't let it suffer. The animal is about 13 to 14 feet long. That is one big disposal problem. I just wish yoiu would have done what I told you to do in the first place and drag it out to sea to be sea food for whomever. That seems to be the natural thing to do. Not euthanize it and then have to drag it out of the water and dispose of it. That is sick.

Posted by: Pithy Opiner, California, USA

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

It's about time someone had some balls to make a decision to put this baby whale at rest. Collins mother did not want him, for what ever reason and at that age it will die for sure. So to all the prima donnas out there carryying on like a pork chop wake up to your selves and let the people do their job without you waisting the courts time and peoples time. Unless yo have a solution which most of us don't then keep out.

Posted by: Joe Gatt, Blacktown

Friday, 22 August 2008

you say the mother didn't want it? have you stopped to think that maybe they were accidentally separate by a boat, sonar pollution or a shark? don't speak just because you have a mouth. Australian's marine 'experts' behaved shamefully! By the way, the most humane thing to do for a starving baby mammal is not to sit around and watch it beg for food, but to FEED IT!!!! KYK8YX VERY SHAMEFUL!!!

Posted by: maria weems, Manly

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Its funny you know how backwards our society is...we chase japanese whalers around the sea protesting about their cruel practises...yet a baby whale is abandoned right under our noses and our final decision is to kill it??? Does anyone see this as a little bit hypocritical?? I mean we are the first to judge people for killing them to satisfy there unsual eating tastes, but what excuses do we have ?? We killed it because it was more of a convenience to make this problem go away then to fix it....

Posted by: pISSD OFF AGAIN, Sydney

Friday, 22 August 2008

Naa mate .. Japan kills inhumanely to eat them. We kill humanely to protect it from suffering. No hypocrisy, in fact nothing highlights our difference more.

Posted by: Paul Williams, Sydney

Friday, 22 August 2008

...so, Paul, are you saying it was humane to do absolutely nothing for over 5 days?! The 'experts' basically sat around and talked about what COULDN'T be done while the poor thing grew weak. I agree that in the end it was most humane to put it down, but what of the previous days?!!? The main discussions were over how expensive it was going to be to care for it for 11 months. Aussie experts and officials had their hands tied with red-tape to do anything in time -- typical Australian bureaucracy!

Posted by: maria weems, manly

Friday, 22 August 2008

It would appear that there are a lot of people with good intentions and even more with a modicum of spare time. If this whale had died at sea it would have done so without a single tear. Chances are it got separated from it's mother because of other practices we all find barbaric - not because a shark decided to tackle it's mother. It is sad, it is definitely a waste of life and a terrible thing to happen to a fragile specialists but it isn't the fault of those who gave up time to help!

Posted by: informed reader, Sydney

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Now that Colin is no more we should be able to do something responsible with his remains. Sell him off in Bits to the japanese restaurants and give the money to charity, at least then something good comes from this. 4000kgs of Whale meat should be worth $40,000 at least. I bet there would be a lot of people out there who want to buy a bit of him, if they couldn't save him, eat him. Yorkie

Posted by: Mark York, Castle Hill

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

I am relieved they have finally put the baby out of it's misery - the chances of a miracle coming were so slim - thanks god common sense took over. For those "angry" people out there - grow up!!! This is life, life is not always fair & you getting angry & carrying on is what's wrong with out society today!!!

Posted by: Deb Glasson, Karratha

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Pissd Off Again - It's just a freakin whale! Are you are prepared to strap on a whale booby and swim around in the freezing water to feed this thing? Maybe we could get a jap mini sub and disguise it as a whale with fake whale boobies and you could pilot it around the harbour feeding it. Again - IT IS JUST A FREAKIN WHALE!

Posted by: Mark Sinclair, Maryland

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Where was Garrett or Wong while this was going on? laying low thats where , wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. gutlesss hypocrites, its probably climate changes fault

Posted by: Pete ex labor, Sydney

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

What about the Australian practice of "never giving up", of "giving it a fair go", "of trying your hardest when the chips are down". Did this happen? NO! Absolutely pathetic. We didn't even try to feed it - NOT ONCE! Very, very sad! There were many who were willing to try, to give it a go, but were not listened to, or given the chance to try.... I hope we have learnt something from this sad experience????

Posted by: Madge Cleall, Bonnet Bay

Friday, 22 August 2008

well said - it's disgusting how the experts and officials handled the matter. hopefully no other whale ever need to rely on australians to help!

Posted by: maria weems, Manly

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Only and idiot will kill this baby humpback whale just goes to show how blind we have become. I am surprised this is not seen as a blessing to help. I hope these experts are not planning to eat it as well being young.

Posted by: Avea Avea, Melbourne

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Gee there are a lot of bleeding hearts out there. Putting Colin down was the last resort and in the end the most humane thing to do. Do the people who say he shouldn't have been put down want Colin to suffer a painful death? At the end of the day it's only a whale it's not like it was someone's family pet. To bleeding hearts get a life and let the experts do their job. They know what best for Colin everone like to think they're an expert.

Posted by: Vicki Mainard, Ballarat

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Just a question to all the "save the whale" people: If you found a dog on the street, dying, no food and cuts everywhere what would you do? It was more humane to put the whale down, its a shame but it was the best thing to do in the situation, it wouldn't have survived, it might have been sick to start with maybe that's why it was abandoned. To be honest they have wasted too much time and resources on a losing battle when there are kids living on the street.

Posted by: Sam L, Sydney

Friday, 22 August 2008

I don't know about you, but if i found a dog in the street who was starving, I wouldn't stand by and watch it beg for food for five days. The baby whale was healthy, lost and hungry when found last Sunday. Five days!!! Of course it's health deteriorated from starvation! By the way, Sam, the most humane thing to do for a starving baby mammal is to FEED IT!!!! not wait for it to weaken and then make the 'humane' excuse to kill it!

Posted by: maria weems, manly

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Thank goodness this is over. Perhaps people can now concentrate on real human suffering that occurs every day, but without the attention of the media. Human children starving is more important than abandonedt baby whales starving.

Posted by: Mick S, Central Coast

 

Friday, 22 August 2008

Paul Williams, you are so right. No one wanted to watch that baby suffer anymore, surely. I wish I had seen the same concern shown for the 12yr old baby left to lay in her backyard to die a few weeks back. I adnire the compassion shown here for baby Colin, but enough is enough. Watching him suffer was harder for me than screaming to keep him alive. He was suffering, why would you want that to continue. For all our wishing to keep him alive, nature is so much bigger than all of us.

Posted by: susan lowe, gippsland