Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Saturday, 22 November 2008

Malcolm Turnbull claims credit for interest rate cut

8/10/2008 10:31:00 AM.  | AAP

Federal Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull says his aggressive stance towards the banks helped borrowers get a better deal from a cut in the official cash rate.

Major banks passed on 80 per cent of yesterday's one percentage point cut in the Reserve Bank's cash rate, reducing by about $150 the monthly repayments on a $300,000 mortgage.

Mr Turnbull had accused the government of abandoning borrowers by not insisting the banks pass on the full interest rate cut.

"I don't think there's anyone listening that imagines that the accountability I've called on the banks to give to their borrowers, has not resulted in them passing on somewhat more than ... they ideally would have liked to pass on," Mr Turnbull told ABC Radio today.

"So in other words, I have stood up for borrowers and I think borrowers have got a better deal as a result."

But Mr Turnbull backed away from suggestions he was taking credit for the size of the cuts.

"I'm not taking credit for any particular amount of it.

"But the reality is that when you call on people to be accountable and to be transparent and justify what they're doing, they have to sit back and think OK how much is this really costing us, how much can we really bear and that causes them to reflect and perhaps be more precise."

However Federal Treasurer Wayne Swan says Mr Turnbull is wrong to think his ego and reckless grandstanding caused banks to pass on most of the rate cut to borrowers.

The treasurer took a swipe at the federal opposition leader today, saying the global financial crisis caused the Reserve Bank to issue a reduction of 100 basis points to the official cash rate.

Before yesterday's announcement, Mr Turnbull advocated banks should pass on all of the rate cut to borrowers.

Banks responded by passing on 80 per cent of the cut, which the federal government supported.

"I know Mr Turnbull thinks that the whole world revolves around his ego, but there are some events in the world which are much bigger than Mr Turnbull's ego," Mr Swan told reporters in Sydney today.

He said the Reserve Bank responded to the global financial crisis by easing monetary policy in Australia and banks acted appropriately."

"It's got absolutely nothing to do with Mr Turnbull," he said.

"The truth is that the international cost of money is through the roof at the moment."

The treasurer called Mr Turnbull's position "reckless grandstanding", but supported further concessions by the banks once the global situation improved.

"Now when the international circumstances normalise, I'd expect the rest of it to be passed on by the bank," he said.

COMMENTS

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Turnbull is really starting to give Rudd a run for his money. Can only improve the standard of government that we (stupidly) elected.

Posted by: Gareth Benson, Blacktown

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

The hollowmen are working overtime, on the news just now Rudd has reportedly said "the banks must pass on the remaining 0.2% when economic conditions stabilise". The next release will probably have Rudd saying precisely the same as Turnbull but with Rudd claiming the credit! Watch this space.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Turnbull is claiming some credit in pressuring the major AUSTRALIAN banks to pass on much of the drop in official cash rates. Swan is now TWISTING this into Turnbull taking credit for The ARB's panic move in the face of an international crisis. Swan doesn't realise that Turnbull would be stupid to put his name on a dubious panic driven undervaluation of the true cost of money. Swan is way beyond his depth.

Posted by: A Narchy, The Hills

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Narchy, Swan has been "way out of his depth" ever since he got the job as treasurer!

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

So Turdbull is claiming credit for the interest rate cut! My god is there anything this man wont say to get his hands on power? Shameful!

Posted by: Traci Fawcett, Melbourne

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Traci Fawcett-You are talking about Rudd surely-say anything, do anything to convince people that he is THE MAN-Strutting the world stage-Nuclear disarmament, Asia bloc, world leadership on Climate Change and addressing an empty UN on the twelve month old credit crisis. Next to him Malcolm is a shrinking violet.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

OMG the sun came up today .... better thank Malcolm Turdbull for that :-) What an out of control egomaniac !

Posted by: Traci Fawcett, Melbourne

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Fawcett, I think the term "out of control egomaniac" better describes Rudd, Mr Photo Opportunity, Mr "I'll fix the world"

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Just wait for the real Turdbill slowly reveal himself Bolty ... A really nasty piece of work - a ruthless egomaniac ... like a Latham on steroids ! Wont take long for the true colours to shine through, trust me! It'll make Rudd look like .... a Brendan Nelson really :-)

Posted by: Traci Fawcett, Melbourne

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Traci Fawcett : Mealy-mouthed comments and based on your own speculation - Turnbull will give Rudd a run for his money and that's already fact!

Posted by: RS ****, Sydney

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

He already has, it will only get better. Swan is floundering, Rudd is still spinning. They are out of their depth and Turnbull doesnt have to say much to expose them as such.

Posted by: susan lawe, gippsland

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Joh used to call it 'feeding the chooks'. Turnbull is 'feeding the idiots' here. This has to be one of the weakest pieces of spin I have ever seen. Like a Kerry O'Keefe half-tracker. The oily Turnbull standing up and saying 'if I don't say so myself, I've just exercised influence over the banks, how good am I', and the pathetic scrambling of the conga line on this site to bathe in his (imagined) reflected glory. I expected more from Turnbill. He is mediocre and embarrassing.

Posted by: darren carrow, brisbane

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Darrow, without doubt Rudd tried to take the pressure off the banks and Turnbull tried to put pressure on the banks. This is indisputable (even to a silly old fossil like you!). In the end, Rudd won, because the banks witheld margin - so that the likes of Commonwealth could buy out their opposition. Even you Darrow can't spin this any other way! You seem noticably rattled (a bit like your hero Kevvie)

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

2 challenges for the battler from Lane Cove. Guaranteed to amke him run like Usain Bolt. Firstly, from what part of my comment do you infer that I am rattled? Or is it just the fact I bother to comment on LibSpin at all? Second, it should be clear to even a casual observer that I hold the coalition in contempt, but where have I ever indictaed that I am a Labor supporter, even once.

Posted by: darren carrow, brisbane

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Darrow, where in my entry did I suggest you were a Labor supporter? If you actually read the entry you will note that I simply contrasted the fact that both leaders had an input and Turnbull seemed to have the best outcome? As for your political leaning, I guess there is only "anarchy" left as your option! I'll leave others to comment on your rattledness. LOL!

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Geoff, so pleased your upper crust digs are echoing with laughter. Your words: "You seem noticably rattled (a bit like your hero Kevvie)" wrong on both counts. Not rattled, and Kevvie is not my hero. There is no doubt about your political leanings. Your rhetorical skill extends only as far as 'looks like (insert name of current seat warming Lib leader) has Rudd rattled' left like a steaming stool on each and every story invovling any political topic.

Posted by: darren carrow, brisbane

Thursday, 09 October 2008

I'm intrigued Darrow, so who is "your hero?". You are anti-anything right of centre (covers the beliefs of half the population). You are not a fan of the left. One can only presume you to be selective anarcistic, communist or fascist? And by the way, don't you agree that Turnbull is giving Rudd a run for his money, and that Turnbull's scrutiny of Rudd will give us all better government?

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Geoff, the internal contradictions in your email are amusing. How can any person be ant-anthing right of centre and also be a fascist? I agree that an effective opposition would be a good thing, but my comments above make it clear that Turnbull is anything but. He appears to be just more of the same old Lib garbage, grandstanding, self-obsessed and not the elast bit concerned with the fate of the Nation, a real disappointment.

Posted by: darren carrow, brisbane

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Darrow (who hasn't answered ANY of my questions yet), many of us (at least half the population see Rudd as "grandstanding, self-obsessed and not the least bit concerned with the fate of the Nation, a real disappointment". Now do you understand? You know where we stand, nobody has a clue (or cares) where you stand.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Thursday, 09 October 2008

hey bolton,ive found in recent weeks carrow to be a very valuable contributor.Ure name calling darren carrow as 'darrow' is boring & stupid,so get off ure arse and see that the world is turning.Ofcourse, i must point out that i am not carrow,u may not believe me(its true tho) but ive realised he usually has an uphill task trying to give valid, commonsense posts amongst large amount of opposing views,usu 2gb rednecks-buggers definitely in the minority here(dont know y u bother daz-"letem bleed"!)

Posted by: Bolton goForaWalk, sydney

Thursday, 09 October 2008

ummm, dont be so sure of ureself bolton. ive found darren to be very insightful and uses commonsense with a hint of spunk.poor bugger is definitely in minority in this site(dont no y u bother, but admire ure tenacity daz).Compare that to bolton & his klanmates posts i'd rather have a beer w/ daz than youse.btw bolton,calling him 'darrow' is unimaginative & useless-how long have u tapped@ pc for now? 8 hours, geez, the world is turning mate,get off ure arse!

Posted by: notDarrenC really, syd

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Poor old Bolts suffering from the fact rates are now lower under Labor.Howards mantra is as dead as him.It is interesting these right wingers all want to claim banks should absorb extra funding costs.What happened to acting in shareholder interest.Do all of the self funded retirees and super fund investors want their returns reduced by the banks generosity.I dont think so.Turnbull knows that directors have fiduciary responsibilities but he chooses to ignore them.You capitalists are kidding!!

Posted by: Lance Freestone,

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

If Freestone classes this panic 1% reduction by the RBA as "good news under Rudd" he might start reflecting on the fact that it wouldn't have been necessary if Swan hadn't egged the RBA on in the first place to rush the rates up. Both Costello and Turnbull early in this year (and Turnbull late last year) were advocating waiting to see what effects the global crisis would have. Rudd ignored this advice. I'm not sure if Freestone understands the plight of self funded retirees?

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

So the GG has the cheek to say Swan is out of his depth.Only a day after the GG predicted rates were headed to 18%.You are a complete idiot who should go back to knitting and keep quiet.

Posted by: Lance Freestone,

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Lance Freestone, - Any fool can bring down interest rates in a slowing economy. Lets hope this is not a repeat of 1991-1992.With Keating at the helm we had interest rates plummet 10%-yes 10% from January 1990 to January 1992.Sadly it was not enough to prevent the 'Recession we had to have'. Hope for everyone’s sake its not a case of déjà vu. The Coalition had the rates at 6% as late as August 2006-in a thriving economy with record breaking job creation. Cheers.

Posted by: Desmond Harris, Beacon Hill

Saturday, 11 October 2008

Perhaps it is you who needs to knit LoonyLance, I was speaking of the last RECESSION we had to have. Started off a little like this one...perhaps you werent old enough to remember...or maybe TOO old to remember anything of fact now almost 20 yrs later.....if you did you would know interest rates went down then too, only to rise again as did inflation, unemployment etc. Grow some manhood L L, and quit sniping at anyone who you dont agree with.

Posted by: susan lawe, gippsland

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

ho hum ,ho hum it will soon be shown once again who is right, however before swan puts his foot in his proverbial, i bet the banks will pass it on

Posted by: allan aitchison, melbourne

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

Finally a politician with some guts, what an impression he has allready made good work Tunbull keep going!

Posted by: maurice maroon, south hurstville

Friday, 17 October 2008

does anyone remember what the interest rates were when howard was treasurer? there was a global recession in progress when keating was in power. hardly his fault. even though interest rates were high, house prices were far lower.you definitely got more for your dollar back then and there was far less debt. compared to now, the keating years were ''the good old days''.

Posted by: trevor crook, wiley pk

 

Wednesday, 08 October 2008

An official cash rate plunge of 1% in one hit is not good news when you consider the international cost of money. That is why Turnbull was careful to only identify himself with the banks passing it on and not the interest rate drop itself. If this does not work out he will crucify Rudd & Swan. Rudd remains silent but Swan does not see it and it will cost him his scalp.

Posted by: A Narchy, The Hills

 

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Turnbull go get a real job, the banks make there own mind up mate not you..You and Bishop from the west are a good laugh when we see you on the tele. Take a leaf out of our refreshing PM Rudd's book and start acting responsible for all Australians.

Posted by: g maybury, sydney

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Maybury, precisely how is "looking after the banks profits" by Rudd, "acting responsible for all Australian?". I must have missed something amongst your deluded rhetoric.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

 

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Geoff Bolton, you have stated "at least half the population see Rudd as "grandstanding, self-obsessed and not the least bit concerned with the fate of the Nation, a real disappointment". If you are going to quote what may loosely be termed statistics, then it is customary to give a source for such statistics. Do you in fact have a source, or is this merely your own invention? Have you carried out a survey of half the entire population (based on your "at least half")?

Posted by: Mick S, Central Coast

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Micks, the election in 2007 saw around half the population vote for Rudd and half vote for Howard. Since then Rudd's popularity has fallen. My simple arithmetic says that "at least half". Use your own brain occasionally, this is Kindy maths.. How many people do you think voted Rudd in?? .....around 50%??

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Geoff, so as I suspected, your 'statistics" are nothing more than the product of your own fevered imagination. Try a good lie down, and seeking some real statistics if you wish to have any credibility. Else, you look rather silly.

Posted by: Mick S, Central Coast

Thursday, 09 October 2008

Micks, one last time for the kiddies. (1) the quote came from Carrow above. (2) the estimate of "over half" is irrefutable (see the kiddie maths in my earlier entry). If you can't understand that, then its obvious why idiots like you support a fool like Rudd.

Posted by: Geoff Bolton, Lane Cove

Saturday, 11 October 2008

You clearly have a very fuzzy idea of what logic is Geoff. Generally, nothing in any of your posts is 'irrefutable', more specifically, posts on this thread by you are easily refutable. This is not kindy maths, it is kindy thinking on your behalf. You consistently assume that what you believe is a 'fact', and other evidence can be safely ignored or discounted without investigation. BTW please state succint que