Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Friday, 09 January 2009

Buchanan attacks video umpire system

4/12/2008 12:31:00 PM.  | Peter Cassidy
Former Australian coach John Buchanan has publically slammed the decision to allow umpires' calls to be challenged by players, insisting it's "the last thing the sport needs".

Buchanan's assault on the system arrives ahead of Australia's three-Test away series against South Africa early next year where a one-match trial of the revolutionary system is planned.

The system allows teams to challenge on-field decisions made by umpires, with any challenges sent to the video umpire for review.

Similar to the system used in the professional tennis circuit, each team will be able to make three unsuccessful challenges per innings.

Should the trials be deemed a success, it's expected to be introduced fulltime.

But Buchanan is adamant the system is flawed.

"The process assumes that technology is 100 per cent accurate - this has never been proven," he told News Ltd.

"This means that all grounds on which international cricket is played must be fitted with exactly the same technology to allow consistency of decision-making around the world.

"What an incredible cost impost to the game, which it can ill afford.

"The game is already littered with too many stoppages. We need umpires to be skilled so they can make the call immediately, and hopefully their success rate will be in the vicinity of 95 per cent for the entire match."

Buchanan even suggested the adoption of the challenge system could have far reaching implications.

What message does that send to young people in our society about challenging authority?" he told News Ltd.

"Kids are going to watch it on television and think it is OK to challenge authority. They need to be taught that all the umpire is doing is policing the laws and you need to abide by those laws. It is as simple as that. This is the last thing the sport needs.

"Challenging the umpire's decision contravenes basic and fundamental law of our western society. Cricket, like golf and possibly a few other sports, upholds the integrity of the game through its recognition that players or officials who bring the game into disrepute, particularly on the field, will be disciplined.

"If we are unhappy with people's competence to administer the law, then spend money and resources to get the right people, get sufficient number of them, get them properly trained, and have them assessed and supported."

COMMENTS

Thursday, 04 December 2008

Im all for it they should use it for lbw's and the faint nicks that are beyond the visual and hearing capacity of geriatric umpires .We have the technology to make make these bungling dinosaurs obsolete ,lets do it . Now its back to Richie and Ian in the commentry box.

Posted by: S lick, WA

 

Thursday, 04 December 2008

So much for the Umpires decision being final. I reckon this is being brought in for the "No red pen brigade". Sooks. Called out, your out, not out is not out. Why bother with an Umpire at all? why not just let a team go in and bat untill bored, then let the others see if they can maintain interest to chase it. Or perhaps, no fielders, so as not to upset the batsmen? ( india's ideal way to play.)

Posted by: Nick Again, Maryborough

Thursday, 04 December 2008

If only Micheal Clarke & Symonds had walked,..but how could the umpires be blamed if he missed seeing MC & Symonds edge,..they only cut the ball to 2nd slip with middle of the bat, anyone can miss that..or if Ponting claims a catch on a ball that bounces a metre in front..lets not question his intergrity...yeah why do we need extra technology when the umpires are serving us okay, & India is spoiling test cric by scoring at 4+ runs/ov,as in last series,.there should be a diff between OD & Test

Posted by: Monk Kee, Coopers Plains

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
LiveNews now available on mobile devices

YOUR SAY

You can beat it Patrick, keep hoping & praying we all love you.... Judy Kennedy, Central Coast on 'I've been through hell': Patrick Swayze on acting with cancer

I would recomend that Israel finishes the job they've started once and for all. Do not finish untill all Hamas terorists are dead and then... Poison Pen, Sydney on Israel fires on targets in Lebanon

I feel this problem goes back to the Whitlam years when kids started getting money to stay at home and have kids, its easier than... Sue Quinn, Bargo on Rosemeadow families lash out at media after court

This has some great information about epilepsy and the myths surrounding it http://www.epilepsy.org.au/fact_sheets/About%20Epilepsy/SS_FactSheets_Exploding_myths_about_epilepsy.pdf. Please take the time to read this, it is important for... Jessica Rabbit, Sydney on Church of Scientology hits back at Jett Travolta drug claims

HI chris I would like to invite you to any family who own a bullmastiff or 2 and have young children For you to denegrade the... Nellie Abela, Bargo on Bullmastiffs must be banned